9 December 2024
|
Update
regarding Vodafone Italy
|
On 15 March 2024, Vodafone Group Plc
("Vodafone") announced that it had entered into a binding agreement
to sell 100% of its Italian operations ("Vodafone Italy") to
Swisscom AG (the "Transaction"). Following the entry into force of
the new UK Listing Rules (the "UKLRs") on 29 July 2024, Vodafone
released a further announcement on 30 September 2024 containing
certain additional information.
Vodafone now sets out further
information relating to the Transaction in accordance with the new
UKLRs.
Appendix 1: Financial
information relating to Vodafone Italy
The following historical financial
information relating to Vodafone Italy's performance has been
extracted without material adjustment from internal financial
accounting records that underlie Vodafone Group Plc's audited
consolidated financial statements for the years ended 31 March 2023
and 31 March 2024, and the unaudited condensed financial statements
for the six months ended 30 September 2024. The audit reports in
respect of these annual consolidated financial statements were
unqualified, and copies of those financial statements are available
on Vodafone's website and at its registered address: Vodafone
House, The Connection, Newbury, Berkshire, RG14 2FN,
England.
The historical financial information
is unaudited, prepared on the basis of Vodafone Group Plc
accounting policies and presented before the elimination of
transactions between Vodafone Italy and the remainder of the
consolidated group.
EY LLP served as the auditor for
Vodafone Group Plc during the periods presented and subsequently up
to the date of this announcement.
Income Statement of Vodafone Italy for the years ended 31
March 2023, 31 March 2024 and the six months ended 30 September
2024:
|
Six months
ended
30 September
2024
|
Year ended
31 March
2024
|
Year ended
31 March
2023
|
|
€m
|
€m
|
€m
|
Revenue
|
2,249
|
4,668
|
4,809
|
Cost of Sales
|
(879)
|
(3,527)
|
(3,619)
|
Gross Profit
|
1,370
|
1,141
|
1,190
|
Selling and distribution
expenses
|
(114)
|
(244)
|
(238)
|
Administrative expenses
|
(302)
|
(869)
|
(816)
|
Net credit losses on financial
assets
|
(26)
|
(51)
|
(66)
|
Operating Profit / (Loss)
|
928
|
(23)
|
70
|
Financing costs
|
(83)
|
(162)
|
(119)
|
Profit / (Loss) before taxation
|
845
|
(185)
|
(49)
|
Income tax expense
|
(260)
|
23
|
10
|
Profit / (Loss) for the financial year from discontinued
operations
|
585
|
(162)
|
(39)
|
After tax loss on the re-measurement
of the disposal group
|
(739)
|
(83)
|
-
|
Loss for the financial year from discontinued
operations
|
(154)
|
(245)
|
(39)
|
Statement of Financial Position of Vodafone Italy as at 31
March 2024 and 30 September 2024:
|
As at
30
September
2024
|
As at
31 March
2024
|
|
€m
|
€m
|
Goodwill
|
1,674
|
2,398
|
Other Intangible Assets
|
3,416
|
3,331
|
Property, Plant and
Equipment
|
4,895
|
4,307
|
Deferred Tax Assets
|
208
|
461
|
Trade and Other receivables due >
1 year
|
143
|
167
|
Non-Current Assets
|
10,336
|
10,664
|
|
|
|
Inventory
|
117
|
134
|
Taxation Recoverable
|
76
|
77
|
Trade and Other receivables due <
1 year
|
1,130
|
1,117
|
Cash and Cash Equivalents
|
28
|
29
|
Current Assets
|
1,351
|
1,357
|
Total Assets held for sale
|
11,687
|
12,021
|
|
|
|
Long Term Borrowings
Total
|
1,387
|
1,509
|
Post Employment Benefits-
Liabilities
|
36
|
45
|
Provisions for Liabilities and
Charges due > 1 year
|
120
|
115
|
Trade and other payables due > 1
year
|
92
|
120
|
Non-Current Liabilities
|
1,635
|
1,789
|
|
|
|
Short Term Borrowings
Total
|
727
|
673
|
Taxation Payable
|
12
|
12
|
Provisions due < 1
year
|
82
|
67
|
Trade and other payables due < 1
year
|
1,440
|
1,723
|
Current Liabilities
|
2,261
|
2,475
|
Total Liabilities held for sale
|
3,896
|
4,264
|
|
|
|
Intercompany loans due > 1
year
|
1,750
|
1,560
|
Other intercompany
|
193
|
196
|
Net
Intercompany
|
1,943
|
1,751
|
|
|
|
Net
Assets
|
5,848
|
6,006
|
Appendix 2: Non-financial
information relating to the Transaction
1. Related party transactions
Details of the related party
transactions that Vodafone has entered into:
· during
the financial year ended 31 March 2022 are set out in note 30 on
page 204 of the Company's 2022 Annual Report;
· during
the financial year ended 31 March 2023 are set out in note 30 on
page 200 of the Company's 2023 Annual Report;
· during
the financial year ended 31 March 2024 are set out in note 30 on
page 216 of the Company's 2024 Annual Report; and
· during
the period from 1 April 2024 to 30 September 2024 are disclosed in
note 13 on page 46 of the Company's interim results for the half
year to 30 September 2024,
in each case, as incorporated by
reference into this announcement. Shareholders can access documents
incorporated by reference at https://investors.vodafone.com/performance/financial-results-and-presentations.
There have been no additional
related party transactions by Vodafone which are relevant to the
Transaction during the period between 30 September 2024, being the
end of the last financial period for which unaudited interim
financial information of Vodafone has been published, and the date
of this announcement.
2. Material contracts
A. Material contracts of the
Retained Vodafone group
No contracts have been entered into
by Vodafone or another member of the Vodafone group, excluding
Vodafone Italy (the "Retained Vodafone Group") (not being contracts
entered into in the ordinary course of business): (i) within the
period of two years immediately preceding the date of this
announcement that are, or may be, material to the Retained Vodafone
Group; or (ii) that contain any provisions under which any member
of the Retained Vodafone Group has any obligation or entitlement
that is, or may be, material to the Retained Vodafone Group, save
as disclosed below.
1. Revolving Credit
Facilities
(A) 2028 Revolving Credit Facility
Vodafone has a USD 3,935,000,000 (as
increased to USD 4,004,000,000) syndicated revolving credit
facility with Barclays Bank plc as successor agent and certain
financial institutions as lenders originally entered into on 27
February 2015 and as amended pursuant to an amendment agreement
dated 10 March 2021, which matures on 10 March 2028.
The facility supports Vodafone's
commercial paper programmes and may be used for general corporate
purposes including acquisitions.
Interest is charged on loans drawn
under the revolving credit facility at a reference rate plus a
margin of 0.375%. Interest periods vary based on the loan
drawn.
The facilities agreement includes
certain events of default that are customary for facilities of this
nature and which are subject to standard grace periods and
materiality thresholds, including, without limitation, non-payment,
breach of other obligations, misrepresentation, cross default,
insolvency-related matters and cessation of business.
As at the date of this announcement,
no amount is outstanding under the facility.
The facility agreement is governed
by English law.
(B) 2029 Revolving Credit Facility
Vodafone has a EUR 3,840,000,000 (as
increased to EUR 4,050,000,000) syndicated revolving credit
facility with Barclays Bank as agent and certain financial
institutions as lenders which it entered into on 28 March 2014 and
as amended by amendment and restatement agreements dated 10 March
2021 and 8 February 2024, which matures on 8 February
2031.
The facility supports Vodafone's
commercial paper programmes and may be used for general corporate
purposes including acquisitions.
Interest is charged on loans drawn
under the revolving credit facility at a reference rate plus a
margin of 0.375%. Interest periods vary based on the loan
drawn.
The facilities agreement includes
certain events of default that are customary for facilities of this
nature and which are subject to standard grace periods and
materiality thresholds, including, without limitation, non-payment,
breach of other obligations, misrepresentation, cross default,
insolvency- related matters and cessation of business.
As at the date of this announcement,
no amount is outstanding under the facility.
The facility agreement is governed
by English law.
2. Vodafone Idea implementation
agreement
On 20 March 2017, erstwhile Vodafone
India Limited ("VIL"), erstwhile Vodafone Mobile Services Limited,
Idea Cellular Limited ("Idea"), Vodafone International Holdings
B.V. and certain VIL promoters and Idea promoters entered into an
implementation agreement pursuant to which the Vodafone group and
the Idea group agreed to combine their mobile telecommunications
businesses in India.
The VIL promoters gave customary
warranties for a transaction of this nature, including as to
capacity and title and received customary warranties in return from
Idea and the Idea promoters.
As part of the implementation
agreement (as amended), the parties agreed a mechanism for payments
between the Vodafone group and Vodafone Idea Limited ("Vodafone
Idea") pursuant to the difference between the crystallisation of
certain identified contingent liabilities in relation to legal,
regulatory, tax and other matters, and refunds relating to Vodafone
India and Idea. Cash payments or cash receipts relating to these
matters must have been made or received by Vodafone Idea before any
amount becomes due from or owed to the Vodafone group. Any future
payments by the Vodafone group to Vodafone Idea as a result of this
agreement would only be made after satisfaction of this and other
contractual conditions.
The Vodafone group's maximum
potential exposure under this mechanism is capped at INR 64
billion.
The final liability calculation date
under the contingent liability adjustment mechanism is 30 June 2025
and no further cash payments are considered probable from the
Vodafone group as at 30 September 2024.
The implementation agreement is
governed by the laws of India.
3. Vantage Towers investment agreement and
shareholders' agreement
On 9 November 2022, Vodafone GmbH
and Oak Consortium GmbH (formerly SCUR-Alpha 1593 GmbH) (the
"Investor"), an entity jointly controlled by Global Infrastructure
Management, LLC, KKR & Co. Inc and other investors (the
"Consortium"), entered into an investment agreement establishing a
co-controlled joint venture (the "JV") for Vantage Towers, which at
that date was listed on the regulated market of the Frankfurt Stock
Exchange (as amended on 22 March 2023).
Vodafone GmbH contributed its shares
in Vantage Towers by way of a capital increase against new JV
shares, while the Consortium agreed to acquire shares in the JV for
cash. Vodafone GmbH and the Investor also agreed that the JV would
make a voluntary takeover offer for the listed Vantage Towers
shares held by minority shareholders.
Vodafone GmbH gave customary
warranties for a transaction of this nature, including as to
capacity and title.
On 23 March 2023, Vodafone GmbH, the
Investor and Oak Holdings 1 GmbH (the JV) entered into a
shareholders' agreement relating to the JV. Rights to appoint
directors to the management board and to appoint members to the
shareholders' committee are tied to the percentage of shares each
of Vodafone GmbH and the Investor holds in the JV. Vodafone GmbH
and the Consortium agreed to a lock-up period of 3 years
post-closing of the transaction, after which each shareholder will
be able to initiate a full or partial sale of its shareholding in
the JV, subject to a right of first offer in favour of the other
shareholder.
The investment agreement and the
shareholders' agreement are governed by the laws of
Germany.
4. Emirates Telecommunications
relationship agreement
On 11 May 2023, Vodafone entered
into a relationship agreement with Emirates Telecommunications
Group Company PJSC ("e&"). Under the terms of the agreement,
subject to relevant regulatory approvals, for so long as e& and
its wholly-owned subsidiaries beneficially own (a) at least 14.6%
of Vodafone's outstanding ordinary shares, e& is entitled to
nominate the e& group CEO to be appointed to the Vodafone Group
Plc board as a non-executive director; and (b) at least 20% of
Vodafone's outstanding ordinary shares, e& will be entitled to
nominate a further independent individual to the Vodafone Group Plc
board as a non-executive director. The e& directors are subject
to annual re-election by Vodafone's shareholders.
The relationship agreement also sets
out terms for the ongoing relationship between e& and Vodafone
in respect of communications, corporate actions and
voting.
Under the terms of the agreement,
e& is subject to a two-year lock-up period and a standstill for
the duration of the agreement (subject to customary carve-outs and
certain permitted actions).
The e& relationship is governed
by English law.
5. Vodafone UK and Three UK contribution
agreement
On 14 June 2023, Vodafone, Brilliant
Design (BVI) Limited (formerly known as Brilliant Design Limited),
CK Hutchison Group Telecom Holdings Limited ("CKHGT"), CK Hutchison
Holdings Limited, Vodafone International Operations Limited and
Vodafone UK Trading Holdings Limited entered into a contribution
agreement under which Vodafone and CKHGT, a wholly owned subsidiary
of CK Hutchison Holdings Limited, agreed to combine their
respective UK businesses, Vodafone UK and Three UK.
Vodafone will have a 51.0% interest
in the combined business ("MergeCo"), with CKHGT holding the
remaining 49.0%.
No cash consideration will be paid
under the agreement, with Vodafone UK and Three UK contributing
differential debt amounts at completion of the transaction to
achieve MergeCo ownership of 51:49. Vodafone UK will be contributed
with £4.3 billion debt and Three UK with £1.7 billion debt, subject
to customary completion adjustments.
Vodafone Group Services Limited, a
wholly-owned subsidiary of Vodafone, has agreed to provide certain
business, technology, IT and corporate function services to MergeCo
and its subsidiaries in the ordinary and usual course of business
in consideration for service charges.
Under the terms of the agreement,
Vodafone International Operations Limited provided certain
customary indemnities for a transaction of this nature to MergeCo
in respect of pre-completion liabilities and liabilities resulting
from pre-completion actions in respect of Vodafone UK. Vodafone
International Operations Limited also gave customary warranties for
a transaction of this nature, including as to capacity and title
and MergeCo also received customary indemnities and warranties from
Brilliant Design (BVI) Limited.
The transaction is subject to
anti-trust and regulatory clearances. As at the date of this
announcement, the transaction has received clearances under the
NSIA Act in the UK, the EU Merger Regulation and from the UK's
Competition and Markets Authority (the "CMA") (subject to legally
binding commitments relating to network investment, retail pricing
and wholesale pricing and contract terms), the Egyptian Competition
Authority and approval by CKHGT's shareholders.
The contribution agreement is
governed by English law.
6. Vodafone Italy sale and purchase
agreement
On 15 March 2024, Vodafone Europe
B.V., Swisscom Italia S.R.L., Vodafone and Swisscom AG entered into
a sale and purchase agreement for the sale of Vodafone's Italian
operations.
The consideration is €8 billion on a
debt and cash free basis, subject to customary closing
adjustments.
The transaction is subject to
certain customary regulatory approvals. As at the date of
this announcement, the transaction has received unconditional
approval from the Presidency of the Council of Ministers in Italy
(Golden Power legislation), the Swiss Competition Commission and
the EU Commission, Directorate-General for Competition, under the
Foreign Subsidies Regulation, Italian Authority for Communications
(Autorità per le Garanzie nelle Comunicazioni, AGCOM) but remains
subject to approval by the Italian Competition Authority (Autorità
Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato) and authorisation under
Article 64 of the Legislative Decree no. 259/2003 with respect to
the transfer of the rights to use frequencies.
Vodafone and Vodafone Europe B.V.
gave customary warranties for a transaction of this nature,
including as to capacity and title and received customary
warranties in return from Swisscom Italia S.r.l. and Swisscom
AG.
The sale and purchase agreement is
governed by Italian law.
B. Material contracts of
Vodafone Italy
No contracts have been entered into
by Vodafone Italy (not being contracts entered into in the ordinary
course of business): (i) within the period of two years immediately
preceding the date of this announcement that are, or may be,
material to Vodafone Italy; or (ii) that contain any provisions
under which Vodafone Italy has any obligation or entitlement that
is, or may be, material to Vodafone Italy, save as disclosed
below.
INWIT master services
agreement
On 25 March 2020, Vodafone Italy and
Infrastrutture Wireless Italiane s.p.a. ("INWIT") entered into a
master services agreement (the "MSA") under which INWIT agreed to
provide to Vodafone Italy, in relation to the sites it operates:
(i) use of the electromagnetic space and related physical areas for
the installation and management of equipment for the use of
Available Frequencies and the supply of the related mobile network
services; (ii) supply of the power and air-conditioning systems,
capable of ensuring the correct power supply and functioning of the
equipment even in the event of a power failure; (iii) monitoring
and security services; (iv) management and maintenance services;
(v) electricity supply services; and (vi) measurement and
monitoring services of the physical and electromagnetic
space.
The MSA has a duration of eight
years and automatically renews for further periods of eight years
unless terminated before the expiry of that term.
The fees paid by Vodafone Italy to
INWIT in relation to the MSA are adjusted each year by the rate of
the consumer price index, provided that this is
positive.
The MSA is governed by Italian
law.
3. Legal and arbitration
proceedings
A. Significant litigation of
the Retained Vodafone group
Save as disclosed below, there are
no governmental, legal or arbitration proceedings (including any
such proceedings which are pending or threatened of which Vodafone
is aware), during the period covering the 12 months preceding the
date of this announcement, which may have, or have had in the
recent past, significant effects on the financial position or
profitability of the Retained Vodafone Group. The proceedings disclosed below are those where the Vodafone
group considers that the likelihood of material future outflows of
cash or other resources is more than remote.
In all cases, determining the
probability of successfully defending a claim against the Retained
Vodafone Group involves the application of judgement as the outcome
is inherently uncertain. The determination of the value of any
future outflows of cash or other resources, and the timing of such
outflows, involves the use of estimates. The costs incurred in
complex legal proceedings, regardless of outcome, can be
significant.
1. VISPL tax claims
Vodafone India Services Private
Limited ("VISPL") is involved in a number of tax cases. As at 30
September 2024, the total value of the claims is approximately €468
million plus interest, and penalties of up to 300% of the
principal. Of the individual tax claims, the most significant is
for approximately €238 million (plus interest of €672 million),
which VISPL has been assessed as owing in respect of: (i) the sale
of an international call centre by VISPL to Hutchison
Telecommunications International Limited group ("HTIL"); and (ii)
the acquisition of and/or the alleged transfer of options held by
VISPL in Vodafone India Limited. Item (i) is subject to an
indemnity by HTIL. Item (ii), which forms the largest part of the
potential claim, is not subject to any indemnity.
A stay of the tax demand was
obtained following a deposit of INR 2,000 million (€22 million)
being paid, and a corporate guarantee being provided by Vodafone
International Holdings BV ("VIHBV") for the balance of tax
assessed. On 8 October 2015, the Bombay High Court ruled in favour
of VISPL in relation to the options and the call centre sale. The
Indian Tax Authority has appealed to the Supreme Court of India.
The appeal hearing has been adjourned indefinitely. A claim in
respect of the transfer pricing margin charged for the
international call centre of HTIL prior to the 2007 transaction
with Vodafone for HTIL assets in India has now been settled. While
there is some uncertainty as to the outcome of the remaining tax
cases involving VISPL, the Vodafone group believes it has valid
defences and does not consider it probable that a financial outflow
will be required to settle these cases.
2. Netherlands tax case
Vodafone Europe BV ("VEBV") received
assessments totalling €267 million of tax and interest from the
Dutch tax authorities, who challenged the application of the arm's
length principle in relation to various intra-group financing
transactions. VEBV entered into a guarantee for the full value of
the assessments issued. VEBV appealed against these assessments to
the District Court of the Hague where a hearing was held in March
2023. The District Court issued its judgement in July 2023,
upholding VEBV's appeal in relation to the majority of issues and
requiring the Dutch tax authorities to significantly reduce its
assessments. VEBV and the Dutch tax authorities have since appealed
the judgement. The appeal hearing is currently scheduled to take
place on 4 February 2025. The Vodafone group continues to believe
it has robust defences but has recorded a provision of €24 million
for tax and interest, reflecting its current view of the probable
financial outflow required to fully resolve the issue and has
reduced the guarantee to the same value.
3. Germany: price increase class
action
In November 2023, the
Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband (Federation of German Consumer
Organisations) initiated a class action against Vodafone Germany in
the Hamm Higher Regional Court. Vodafone Germany implemented price
increases of €5 per month for fixed lines services in 2023 in
response to higher costs. The claim alleges that terms regarding
price increases in the consumer contracts entered into by Vodafone
Germany's customers up until August 2023 are invalid under German
civil law and seeks reimbursement of the additional charges plus
interest. Customers must enter their details onto the register of
collective actions on the Federal Office of Justice website in
order to participate in the claim. The register opened on 23 April
2024. Whilst the Vodafone group intends to defend the claim, it is
not able to determine the likelihood or estimate the amount of any
possible financial loss at this early stage of the
proceedings.
4. Germany: claims regarding transfer of
data to credit agencies
Individual consumers are bringing
claims against Vodafone Germany and/or the other national network
operators alleging that information was passed to credit agencies
up to February 2024 about contracts for mobile services without
consumer consent. The claims seek damages of up to €5,000 per
contract for GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation)
infringement. As at 15 November 2024, Vodafone Germany had been
notified of 482 claims filed in various regional courts. The other
national network operators are facing similar claims. Vodafone
Germany's position is that the transfer of data about the existence
of a consumer contract (and not about payments in relation to the
contract) to credit agencies is standard practice and justified for
the purposes of fraud prevention. However, given the increasing
volume of claims, Vodafone Germany has stopped this activity.
Although the outcome of these claims is uncertain and consequently
it is not possible to estimate a potential financial loss, if any,
at this stage, the Vodafone group believes it has valid defences
and that no present obligation exists based on all available
evidence.
5. Germany: investigation by federal data
protection authority
In 2021, the BfDI (Federal
Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information)
started an investigation into potential breaches of the GDPR in
relation to the systems used by Vodafone Germany sales partners to
manage customer data. Vodafone Germany is working cooperatively
with the authority to discuss the circumstances giving rise to
these issues and is currently conducting settlement talks with the
aim of reaching a constructive resolution of the proceedings. Under
the GDPR the authority has the power to impose fines of up to 2% of
the Vodafone group's annual revenue from the preceding financial
year. A provision immaterial to the financial statements has been
recorded.
6. Greece: Papistas Holdings SA, Mobile
Trade Stores (formerly Papistas SA) and Athanasios and Loukia
Papistas v Vodafone Greece
In October 2019, Mr. and Mrs.
Papistas, and companies owned or controlled by them, filed several
claims against Vodafone Greece with a total value of approximately
€330 million for purported damage caused by the alleged abuse of
dominance and wrongful termination of a franchise arrangement with
a Papistas company. Lawsuits which the Papistas claimants had
previously brought against Vodafone Greece, including one also
citing Vodafone and certain Directors and officers of Vodafone as
defendants, were either withdrawn or left dormant. Vodafone Greece
filed a counter claim and all claims were heard in February 2020.
All of the Papistas claims were rejected by the Athens Court of
First Instance because the stamp duty payments required to have the
merits of the case considered had not been made. Vodafone Greece's
counter claim was also rejected. The Papistas claimants and
Vodafone Greece each filed appeals. The appeal hearings took place
on 23 February and 11 May 2023. Judgement has been received and the
Court dismissed both of the appeals because the stamp duty payments
had again not been made, except for one aspect of the proceedings
which will be dealt with at a further hearing in February 2025.
Whether the Papistas claimants will appeal the judgement is unknown
as at the date of this announcement. Vodafone Greece is continuing
vigorously to defend the claims and based on the progress of the
litigation so far the Vodafone group believes that it is highly
unlikely that there will be an adverse ruling. On this basis, the
Vodafone group does not expect the outcome of these claims to have
a material financial impact.
7. UK: Phones 4U in Administration v
Vodafone Limited, Vodafone Group Plc and Others
In December 2018, the administrators
of former UK indirect seller, Phones 4U, sued the three main UK
mobile network operators ("MNOs"), including Vodafone UK, and their
parent companies in the English High Court. The administrators
alleged collusion between the MNOs to withdraw their business from
Phones 4U thereby causing its collapse. The judge ordered that
there should be a split trial between liability and damages. The
first trial on liability took place from May to July 2022. On 10
November 2023, the High Court issued a judgement in Vodafone and
Vodafone UK's favour and rejected Phones 4U's allegations that the
defendants were in breach of competition law, consistent with
Vodafone's previously stated position that a present obligation
does not exist. Phones 4U has been granted permission to appeal the
judgement from the Court of Appeal. The appeal hearing will take
place in May 2025. Vodafone and Vodafone UK intend to vigorously
defend the appeal and the Vodafone group is not able to estimate
any possible loss in the event of an adverse judgement on
appeal.
8. South Africa: Kenneth Makate v Vodacom
(Pty) Limited
Mr Kenneth Makate, a former employee
of Vodacom Pty Limited ("Vodacom South Africa"), started legal
proceedings in 2008 claiming compensation for a business idea that
led to the development of a service known as "Please Call Me"
("PCM").
In July 2014, the Gauteng High Court
("the High Court") ruled that Mr Makate had proven the existence of
a contract, but that Vodacom South Africa was not bound by that
contract because the responsible director did not have authority to
enter into such an agreement on Vodacom South Africa's behalf. The
High Court and Supreme Court of Appeal ("the SCA") turned down Mr
Makate's application for leave to appeal in December 2014 and March
2015, respectively. In April 2016, the Constitutional Court of
South Africa ("the Constitutional Court") granted leave to appeal
and upheld Mr Makate's appeal. It found that Vodacom South Africa
is bound by the agreement and ordered the parties to negotiate, in
good faith, and agree a reasonable compensation amount payable to
Mr Makate or, in the event of a deadlock, for the matter to be
referred to Vodacom Group's Chief Executive Officer ("the CEO") to
determine such compensation amount. Mr Makate's application for the
aforementioned order to be varied from the determination of an
amount to a compensation model based on a share of revenue, was
dismissed by the Constitutional Court. In accordance with the
Constitutional Court order, and after negotiations failed, the CEO
issued his determination on 9 January 2019. However, the CEO's
award of R47 million (€2.4 million) was rejected by Mr Makate, who
subsequently brought an application in the High Court for the
review of the CEO's determination and award. The High Court, in a
judgement delivered on 8 February 2022, set aside the CEO's
determination and ordered him to reassess the amount employing a
set of criteria which would have resulted in the payment of a
higher compensation amount, for the benefit of Mr Makate, than that
determined by the CEO. Vodacom South Africa appealed against the
judgement and the order of the High Court to the SCA. The SCA heard
the appeal on 9 May 2023 and its judgement was handed down on 6
February 2024. A majority of three judges, with a minority of two
judges dissenting, dismissed the appeal and ruled that Mr Makate is
entitled to be paid 5% - 7.5% of the total revenue of the PCM
product from March 2001 to the date of the judgement, plus
interest. On 27 February 2024, Vodacom South Africa applied for
leave to appeal the judgement and order of the SCA to the
Constitutional Court, resulting in the suspension of the operation
of the judgement and order of the SCA. On 26 August 2024, the
Constitutional Court issued a directive that it will hear Vodacom
South Africa's application for leave to appeal in tandem with its
appeal against the SCA judgement and order. The record of the
proceedings in the SCA, with relevant annotations, was filed in the
Constitutional Court on 26 September 2024. Vodacom South Africa, as
the applicant, filed its written arguments on 10 October 2024 and
Mr Makate filed his response on 18 October 2024. The matter was
heard by the Constitutional Court on 21 November 2024 and judgment
was reserved.
Vodacom South Africa is challenging
the SCA's judgement and order on various grounds including, but not
limited to the SCA ignoring the evidence placed before it on the
computation of the quantum of compensation payable to Mr Makate,
and the SCA issuing orders that are incapable of implemented and
enforced. The CEO's determination in 2019 amounted to R47 million
(€2.4 million). The minority judgement of the SCA raised Mr
Makate's compensation to an amount payable of R186 million (€9.6
million). The value of the compensation amount for Mr Makate, as
per the SCA's majority judgement and order, would at a minimum be
R29 billion (€1.5 billion). Mr Makate, in his recent submissions to
the Constitutional Court, has stated that his request is for
compensation in the capital amount of R9.4 billion (€493 million),
plus interest from 18 January 2019. Consequently, the range of the
possible compensation outcomes in this matter is very wide. The
amount ultimately payable to Mr Makate is uncertain and will depend
on the success of Vodacom South Africa's appeal against the
judgement and order of the SCA, on the merits of the case. The
Vodafone group is continuing to challenge the level of compensation
payable to Mr Makate and a provision immaterial to the financial
statements has been recorded.
9. UK: Mr Justin Gutmann v
Vodafone Limited and Vodafone
In November 2023, Mr Gutmann issued
claims in the Competition Appeal Tribunal seeking permission, as a
proposed class representative, to bring collective proceedings
against the four UK MNOs and, in the case of Vodafone Limited and
EE Ltd, their respective parent companies. Vodafone and Vodafone
Limited are named defendants in one of the claims with an alleged
value of £1.4 billion (approximately €1.6 billion), including
interest. It is alleged that Vodafone, Vodafone Limited and the
other MNOs used their alleged market dominance to overcharge
customers after the expiry of the minimum terms of certain mobile
contracts (referred to as a "loyalty penalty"). Taking into account
all available evidence at this stage, the Vodafone group's
assessment is that the allegations are without merit and it intends
to defend the claim. The Vodafone group is currently unable to
estimate any possible loss in regards to this issue but, while the
outcome is uncertain, the Vodafone group believes it is probable
that no present obligation exists.
B. Significant litigation of
Vodafone Italy
Save as disclosed below, there are
no governmental, legal or arbitration proceedings (including any
such proceedings which are pending or threatened of which Vodafone
is aware), during the period covering the 12 months preceding the
date of this announcement, which may have, or have had in the
recent past, material effects on the financial position or
profitability of Vodafone Italy.
Italy: Iliad v Vodafone
Italy
In July 2019, Iliad filed a claim
for €500 million against Vodafone Italy in the Civil Court of
Milan. The claim alleges anti-competitive behaviour in relation to
customer portability and certain advertising campaigns by Vodafone
Italy. The main hearing on the merits of the claim took place on 8
June 2021. On 17 April 2023, the Civil Court issued a judgement in
Vodafone Italy's favour and rejected Iliad's claim for damages in
full. Iliad filed an appeal before the Court of Appeal of Milan in
June 2023. The appeal process is ongoing. The Vodafone group is
currently unable to estimate any possible loss in this claim in the
event of an adverse judgement on appeal but, while the outcome is
uncertain, the Vodafone group believes it has valid defences and
that it is probable that no present obligation exists.
4. Significant change statement
On 14 November 2024, Vodafone
announced that it will commence the third tranche of a share
repurchase programme of ordinary shares up to a maximum
consideration of €500 million ending no later than 3 February
2025. On 5 December 2024, Vodafone announced that the
combination of Vodafone UK and Three UK had been approved by the
CMA. The approval is subject to legally binding commitments
relating to network investment, retail pricing and wholesale
pricing and contract terms. There have been no other
significant changes in the financial position of the Retained
Vodafone Group since 30 September 2024, the end of the last
financial period for which unaudited interim financial information
has been published.
There has been no significant change
in the financial position of Vodafone Italy since 30 September
2024, the end of the last financial period for which unaudited
interim financial information has been published.
Notes
Information that is itself
incorporated by reference into the above documents is not
incorporated by reference into this document. It should be noted
that, except as set forth above, no other portion of the above
documents is incorporated by reference into this document and those
portions which are not specifically incorporated by reference into
this document are either not relevant for Shareholders or the
relevant information is included elsewhere in this
document.
Any statement contained in a
document which is deemed to be incorporated by reference herein
shall be deemed to be modified or superseded for the purpose of
this document to the extent that a statement contained herein (or
in a later document which is incorporated by reference herein)
modifies or supersedes such earlier statement (whether expressly,
by implication or otherwise). Any statement so modified or
superseded shall not be deemed, except as so modified or
superseded, to constitute a part of this document.
The contents of Vodafone's website
or any hyperlinks accessible from it do not form part of this
document and investors should not rely on them.
- ends
-
About Vodafone
Vodafone is a leading European and
African telecoms company. We provide mobile and fixed services to
over 330 million customers in 15 countries (excludes Italy which is
held as a discontinued operation under Vodafone Group), partner
with mobile networks in 45 more and have one of the world's largest
IoT platforms. In Africa, our financial technology businesses serve
almost 83 million customers across seven countries - managing more
transactions than any other provider.
Our purpose is to connect for a
better future by using technology to improve lives, businesses and
help progress inclusive sustainable societies. We are committed to
reducing our environmental impact to reach net zero emissions by
2040.
For more information, please
visit www.vodafone.com follow us on X at @VodafoneGroup or connect with us on
LinkedIn at www.linkedin.com/company/vodafone.
About Swisscom
Swisscom is the leading ICT company
in Switzerland and, with Fastweb, a leading challenger in Italy.
The company offers mobile, Internet and TV, as well as
comprehensive IT and digital services to private and business
customers. Swisscom is listed on the Swiss Stock Exchange and is
51% owned by the Swiss Confederation.