As online broker E*Trade Financial Corp. (ETFC) awaits word from
the Treasury Department on an $800 million investment, the
company's options to raise capital are shrinking.
The New York company applied for funds from the federal
government's Troubled Asset Relief Program to offset mortgage woes
in its banking unit. While it waits for a response from regulators,
E*Trade plans to sell off more of its non-core assets and cancel
some of its outstanding debt by exchanging bonds for equity,
efforts it has pursued in prior quarters.
Analysts say, however, that E*Trade already sold off a majority
of its non-essential businesses. Although the company has already
set aside $1.1 billion to offset losses from bad loans, the amount
might not be enough to cover rising delinquencies in its bank
subsidiary's mortgage portfolio. These factors make TARP funding
increasingly important for E*Trade.
E*Trade's bank has a Tier 1 capital ratio - a measure of
financial strength - of 6.29%. That level is high enough for the
bank to be considered well capitalized. But in the recession,
regulators have informally considered 8% a better target ratio for
banks.
In a note to clients Monday, Barclays Capital analyst Roger
Freeman wrote that he expects E*Trade to "narrowly avoid breaching
the well-capitalized" threshold for Tier 1. But he said E*Trade
will need some other capital to shore up its bank in the absence of
TARP.
In an interview Jan. 27, Chief Executive Donald Layton said that
the company's capital ratios are at "fine levels." During a call
with analysts that day, he said E*Trade would generate about $1
billion or more in capital at its bank through earnings and
shrinking its balance sheet. E*Trade can also inject $435 million
from the parent company into its bank, or make payments in kind
(instead of interest payments) on notes due in 2017, which could
save up to $410 million.
Shares of E*Trade in morning trading were flat at $1.16. The
company's stock has plunged more than 75% over the past year, due
to the bank unit's troubles and also in line with weakness in
financial stocks.
Capital Measures
In its fourth quarter, E*Trade set aside $512.9 million for loan
losses, down from $517.8 million in the third quarter.
E*Trade also reported risk-based capital of $716 million, up
from $435.1 million a year earlier.
Standard & Poor's analyst Rikin Pandya said, "we applaud
E*Trade's aggressive reserving, but believe that it needs more
capital to ease investor uncertainty."
That uncertainty stems from mortgage losses within E*Trade's
banking unit, which has offset any growth in its brokerage
business.
In E*Trade's home equity portfolio, total delinquent loans rose
20% in the fourth quarter over the third, and 44% year-over-year.
The company said delinquencies spiked in November, but added that
the trend was "not repeated in December and January."
Loans to residences housing one to four families are the bread
and butter of E*Trade's bank. Those loans have also deteriorated in
the fourth quarter. In the portfolio, which accounts for roughly
one-fourth of the company's total assets, total delinquent loans
increased 38% over the third quarter and more than doubled
year-over-year. Total charge-offs, or loans that the company
doesn't think it can collect, were 1.74% of average loans
receivable, sharply up from 0.1% a year ago.
E*Trade says that its vintage loans, of which it has a higher
percentage than its peers, are being paid back faster than those of
its competitors. The company also says nearly 50% of its loans that
were issued before 2007 are less likely to default.
Industry observers, however, project that with a weak economic
environment, charge-offs and delinquencies will increase in 2009 -
making further capital-raising a virtual necessity for E*Trade.
Within its home equity portfolio, E*Trade itself expects
charge-offs to rise 15% to 20% over its previous $1.8 billion
estimate for 2008 to 2010.
"The bottom line is, capital ratios didn't move very much from
the third quarter," said Alexander Yavorsky, assistant vice
president of Moody's Finance and Securities team. They are "not
especially strong, but still remain above well capitalized
levels."
Sandler O'Neill analyst Richard Repetto recently estimated that
an $800 million TARP investment would increase E*Trade's Tier 1
ratio to 7.91%.
Others, however, say that E*Trade's capital ratios are not
likely to fall much further, given the severe beating that the
company has taken from turmoil in the housing market.
E*Trade "took two quarters in a row of loan loss provisions over
$500 million, it's going to take something catastrophic to get them
below 6%," Pandya said.
With Or Without TARP?
Meanwhile, E*Trade's near-term alternatives for capital include
selling more non-core assets. E*Trade raised $754 million from such
transactions, including the sale of its Canadian operations, in
2008. In November, the company also converted $450 million of debt
to equity at $18 a share.
Debt-for-equity swaps, however, could risk further diluting
shareholder value, though E*Trade has been trading at just over $1
a share for the past three months. The company avoided such deals
in the third quarter, citing the "unattractive price of both its
equity and bonds."
There's also a question of what terms could be placed on E*Trade
to receive government funds. While E*Trade has been shrinking its
balance sheet as it stopped originating and purchasing loans at the
beginning of 2007, the company said that if it receives TARP
approval, it would again finance home mortgages. E*Trade plans to
purchase Fannie Mae (FNM) and Freddie Mac (FRE) guaranteed
mortgage-backed secruities.
Raymond James analyst Patrick O'Shaughnessy said that with the
plan, he doesn't think E*Trade is "strategically or operationally
aligned with the stated intention of the federal program."
The company could also be a candidate for the so-called "bad
bank" plan being considered by the federal government to buy a
portion of toxic assets from financial institutions. The initiative
and its details have yet to be announced.
On the call last week, Layton said, "it may be another arrow in
the quiver we get to look at to improve the balance sheet of the
company."
-By Brett Philbin, Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-5393;
brett.philbin@dowjones.com
Click here to go to Dow Jones NewsPlus, a web front
page of today's most important business and market news, analysis
and commentary. You can use this link on the day this article is
published and the following day.