Globe and Mail newspaper fails again to tell the whole story about mining-related events and policies in Mongolia
13 September 2006 - 4:55PM
PR Newswire (US)
Statement by John Macken, President and CEO, Ivanhoe Mines
----------------------------------------------------------
VANCOUVER, Sept. 13 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- A story published in
the Toronto-based Globe and Mail newspaper today fails again to
provide readers with the whole story, in an accurate and balanced
manner, arising from a two-day mining conference in Ulaanbaatar,
Mongolia. The alarmist and misleading story headline claims that
"Mongolia is ready to grab stake in Ivanhoe Mine," with the
secondary headline: "New law could see state owning 34%." Even the
seriously flawed story fails to support the obsessively negative
headline. Neither the story, nor any representative of the
Mongolian government, has said that the government is about to
seize interests in any mining projects in the country. An
implication of a grab, or seizure, is that such action could be
taken without consent or fair compensation. But that is not the
case. In fact, the newspaper story beneath the headline reports
that the government of Mongolia will not confiscate interests in
any projects, including Ivanhoe's Oyu Tolgoi copper and gold mine
development project, and will indeed ensure that any interest is
acquired on a "commercial basis." The story also makes it clear
that if the government actually does decide to acquire an interest
in Oyu Tolgoi, for example, the interest could be anywhere from 1%
up to a maximum of 34% - an important qualification ignored by the
headline, which can only create confusion and concern among
investors. Ivanhoe previously addressed the issue of potential
state participation in a news release issued more than two months
ago. Beyond the headline, the story's principal failings include
the following: - There is nothing in the story to indicate that the
government of Mongolia has decided to exercise its recently
approved legislative option to acquire a stake in the Oyu Tolgoi
project. The newspaper quotes only the view of a single cabinet
minister, who is not even a member of the governing majority MPR
party. - There is nothing in the story to show that the government
might attempt to negotiate a stake in the project before there is a
clear mechanism to ensure that the company receives a fair price
for any such interest. The newspaper once again is indulging in
alarmist, harmful speculation. - The newspaper failed to report
that the leader of the MPRP caucus in the national parliament, D.
Idevkhen, emphatically told the conference today that the
government has the option to acquire up to 34% of strategic mineral
deposits discovered without the use of state funds - "not 34%; up
to 34%." Mr. Idevkhen declared that if the government decides to
exercise its option, "rest assured that the government...will
invest...through equity participation by purchasing their shares or
maybe even through tax negotiations and preferential tax
treatment." The issue, he said, will be addressed by the
parliament. - The newspaper also failed to report that Mr. Idevkhen
told investors: "Your investment wishes and desires will be met by
the Mongolian government and state. The Mongolian government will
remain committed to securing stability of the investment
environment." - The newspaper failed to report that several
prominent government and opposition members of Parliament told the
mining conference that the windfall profits tax adopted by the
Mongolian parliament in May will either be rescinded, or
substantially modified to reduce its potential financial impact on
mining companies. Mr. Idevkhen, leader of the governing MPRP caucus
in Parliament, said earlier today: "I am convinced that this law
will not live long." Mr.Idevkhen's comments have been widely
reported in a more fair and balanced context earlier today by
Reuters and Bloomberg international news services. Some opposition
members of parliament were more scathing in their criticism of the
windfall-profits tax law. - As government representatives have
previously stated, the tax on higher-priced copper concentrates
will not apply if the concentrates are processed in a smelter in
Mongolia. Ivanhoe has previously stated that it will work with the
government of Mongolia to establish smelting capacity in Mongolia,
which could handle Oyu Tolgoi concentrates. Ivanhoe has been
approached by several parties with proposals to finance a smelter.
- The newspaper failed to report that demonstrators supporting
foreign investment and development of Mongolia's mineral resources
lined the entrance to the conference hall carrying signs with
messages for delegates that included: "Mining is the future of
Mongolia," and "Foreign investment in the mining sector creates
jobs." CONTACT: Information contacts : Investors: Bill Trenaman;
Media: Bob Williamson (604) 688-5755 DATASOURCE: Ivanhoe Mines Ltd.
CONTACT: Information contacts : Investors: Bill Trenaman; Media:
Bob Williamson (604) 688-5755
Copyright