Wirecard Shares Drop on Lack of Audit Opinion for Singapore Arm
By Paul J. Davies
Shares of Wirecard AG, the German electronic payments company
whose accounting practices in Asia are under investigation, fell
Wednesday after it emerged that an auditor hadn't fully signed off
on its Singapore arm's most recent accounts.
The company, which denies all allegations of improper accounting
practices, said the lack of a final opinion from Ernst & Young
for Wirecard Singapore Pte's accounts didn't affect the audit of
the parent firm for 2017 and 2018.
Wirecard is among Europe's biggest and fastest-growing fintech
companies. Last year, it broke into the DAX 30 index of Germany's
top firms, displacing local lender Commerzbank AG.
However, its rapidly appreciating share price -- at its peak
last September, the stock had more than quadrupled in value over
the previous two years -- along with a string of acquisitions and
limited financial disclosure have helped make it a target for short
sellers, who borrow stock and sell it with the goal of buying back
the securities later for less money.
Its shares dropped 3.3% in European trading, after having
declined more than 7% earlier in the day.
The company has been dealing with questions over its Asian
accounting practices following a series of articles in the
Financial Times this year. The company has denied the allegations,
which related to how it records revenue and fictitious invoicing.
The Singaporean police's Commercial Affairs Department later opened
an investigation and seized files from the company's local
The Singapore arm reported S$40 million in revenue for 2017, a
relatively small part of the group, but Singapore is more important
as a hub for Wirecard's business throughout Asia.
Wirecard attracted what initially appeared to be a $1 billion
confidence-boosting investment from SoftBank Group in April. The
Wall Street Journal reported last week that the Japanese group put
no money into the deal.
Ernst & Young in October issued a so-called disclaimer of
opinion for Wirecard's Singaporean accounts for 2017, as first
reported by Germany's Handelsblatt newspaper on Tuesday. The
subsidiary's accounts for the year ended Dec. 31, 2018, have not
The auditor said it was unable to obtain sufficient and
appropriate evidence to provide a basis for an audit opinion on the
2017 statements because of the police investigation, staff turnover
at Wirecard Singapore, and work by other external firms appointed
to conduct an independent review.
"The outcome of these investigations may uncover other
information which might require adjustments and/or additional
disclosures," the disclaimer in the 2017 accounts said. The extent
of any potential required adjustments isn't known, it said.
Another Singaporean unit, Wirecard Asia Holding Pte, posted 2017
accounts in February with an unqualified opinion from local auditor
RSM Chio Lim.
The Singaporean issues come at an awkward time for Wirecard,
which like other payments companies in the Southeast Asian
city-state must apply for a license to operate next year under new
regulations that come into force in January.
Wirecard and some observers expect existing operators to get a
grace period to obtain that license.
Wirecard said it had no doubt the Monetary Authority of
Singapore will issue it a license. It also expects to be given
until the end of 2020 to complete its application.
"We do not see any direct correlation between the investigation
and the license approval process, nor has the MAS made any
statements to us in that regard," a Wirecard spokeswoman said.
The MAS said it was unable to comment on whether a company would
qualify for a license without a full review of its application.
Wirecard added that the reporting of its 2018 financial
statements for Singapore was close to completion. The Wirecard Asia
Holding unit also has not filed 2018 accounts yet.
Write to Paul J. Davies at email@example.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
November 20, 2019 12:36 ET (17:36 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Historical Stock Chart
Von Jul 2020 bis Aug 2020
Historical Stock Chart
Von Aug 2019 bis Aug 2020