Corporate HR Department Is Wall Street's Next Battleground
13 Februar 2019 - 1:26AM
Dow Jones News
By Liz Hoffman
The hottest new client on Wall Street: corporate human-resources
managers.
Investment banks better known for big trades and megamergers are
descending from the C-suite to pitch for business managing
companies' employee-benefit programs. It isn't a glamorous business
but it offers the type of sticky, predictable revenue that bank
shareholders want -- and executives are willing to embrace -- as
core Wall Street businesses struggle.
On Monday, Morgan Stanley agreed to acquire Solium Capital Inc.,
which manages employee stock awards for 3,000 companies. Goldman
Sachs Group Inc. is building a wealth-management tool that it plans
to pitch to corporate HR managers in the next year or so.
The competition is formidable. Retail brokerages such as
Fidelity Investments, Charles Schwab Corp. and E*Trade Financial
Corp. dominate the business, bundling employee stock grants,
retirement plans, health-savings accounts and other services. They
have added financial advisers, banking products and low-cost trades
to win the loyalty of these customers.
Newcomers also must be mindful of Wall Street's reputation for
unsavory sales practices, especially after the scandal at Wells
Fargo & Co. Goldman's contract to build a financial-education
website for Google parent Alphabet Inc. prevents the bank from
pitching Google employees on savings accounts, loans or other
products, according to people familiar with the matter.
Goldman has launched similar websites for 70 companies covering
more than 1 million workers. They offer checklists and quizzes and
assign workers a financial-health score that they are encouraged to
improve.
Investment banks are looking for steadier sources of revenue to
replace declines in securities-trading and principal investments.
Goldman said it made 61% of its money last year from more-recurring
businesses such as asset management and lending, up from 48% in
2013. Morgan Stanley has shifted thousands of clients from accounts
that collect trading commissions, which increase in hot markets but
fall in cold ones, into accounts that charge a steady annual
fee.
Investors, still whipsawed from the financial crisis and the
rogue-trading scandals that followed, assign higher value to these
revenues. Executives hope that growing and highlighting them will
boost their companies' stock prices.
Morgan Stanley is leading with its wealth-management arm, which
manages about $2.3 trillion. It hopes to convert Solium's 1 million
employee-clients into customers of that business, and has hired
executives from E*Trade and Schwab over the past year to bulk up
its appeal among rank-and-file employees, who tend to be younger
and less wealthy.
"We were really good at capturing the C-suite," said Morgan
Stanley Chief Financial Officer Jonathan Pruzan. "But we weren't
touching the tens of thousands of incremental employees. Part of
the appeal of this deal is access to those millions of
customers."
Goldman, meanwhile, is seeking customers for Goldman's new
consumer bank Marcus, whose growth is a key priority for its new
chief executive, David Solomon. It has spent tens of millions of
dollars on direct mail, advertising and referrals. Corporate
contracts can bring in tens of thousands of potential customers in
one swoop and generate revenue to boot.
"It's all about customer-acquisition costs," said Devin Ryan, an
analyst with JMP Securities. "This is a way to get a foot in the
door."
Both Goldman and Morgan Stanley are leaning on their investment
bankers to make introductions at big companies. Those bankers are
well connected in C-suites, especially in Silicon Valley, where
employee stock grants are ubiquitous.
Those companies increasingly want more than record-keeping, and
expect financial wellness and coaching, said Amy Reback, who runs
Schwab's stock-plan service. "That's a big change from five or 10
years ago," she said.
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
February 12, 2019 19:11 ET (00:11 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.